“The New Sentience: Reimaging Animal Poetry” edited by Ashley Capps and Allison Titus

The New Sentience: Reimagining Animal Poetry (Trinity University Press 2026), an anthology edited by Ashley Capps and Allison Titus, is in many ways a radical collection of poetry and in all ways is a significant, profound, and powerful collection. These are not the sweet sentimental verses about beloved pets—although there are poems of pets and poems with great tenderness—but rather, poems that as the introduction states “are true outliers in the tradition of animal poetry.” These important poems are “engaging animals as autonomous individuals…exploring animal life with respect, curiosity, empathy, and humility.”

Be prepared. With their unflinching intensity and emotional renderings, the poems in The New Sentience might well leave readers breathless. Often visceral, these works use various poetic devices to champion the idea “that there is a sacredness inherent in all creatures” and the poems do so with a punch. Rarely gentle and never timid, these are verses that in varying ways, styles, and formats embrace the belief that “all life is equal, and of equal concern.”

The fascinating, scholarly introduction alone is worth buying the book for and certainly sets the stage well for the poems that follow. Written with compassion, insight, an intellectual bent, and thoroughly footnoted, this introduction recognizes “sentience [is] defined as the capacity to feel, perceive, or experience subjectivity—including the ability to experience pleasure and suffering.” The poems certainly shine a bold light on the ability of non-human life forms to experience such feelings, including a profound desire to continue living. For example, in Mary Oliver’s “Clam,” she writes, “Each one is a small life. / … Like us, they have a heart and a stomach; they know/  hunger, and probably a little satisfaction too.” She concludes: “They have resources / beyond the flesh; they also try very hard not to die.”

Animals in the Western culture poetry tradition, per the introduction, have long been used as “consumable symbols,” operating more as metaphors and props rather than actual sentient beings. That is, quoting author Allison Davis, “the deer is the prop, not the point.” In stark contrast to this history, the nonhuman animals in the poems in this collection are the point and not the metaphor. For example, in Gretchen Primack’s poem, “When I Got There the Dead Opossum Looked Like,” she notes, “He did not want a majestic / burial as majestic burials are inane. He wanted / his family back. He wanted to live but / we wouldn’t let him.”

Another fine example of the animal being the point and not the prop is found in Elizabeth Bishop’s “The Fish,” in which the narrator “caught a tremendous fish / …battered and venerable/ …While his gills were breathing in / this terrible oxygen…I looked into his eyes…” After a precise and descriptive rendition in which the poet finally and fully sees the fish as something alive and deserving to live, the poem ends “And I let the fish go.” And Miller Oberman addresses the metaphor issue straight on in the poem “Joy,” which speaks of “just some common loons—not metaphors / in any way, just real loons in a lake swimming / near each other…”

Within these poems, rage and grief often form an unquenching and chilling reality for the animals and the ways in which they are treated both deliberately and accidentally. In “Big Pig,” poet Gretchen Primack writes directly about that with her lines:

Big pig, smart and fattened

to grotesque, I am not better

than you, though I am different:

I can speak my rage, build your crate.

In Les Murray’s “The Cows on Killing Day,” the poet describes slaughter from the cow’s point of view, beginning with the lines “All me are standing on feed. The sky is shining.”  But then: “A stick goes out from the human / and cracks, like the whip. Me shivers and falls down / with the terrible, the blood of me, coming out…” On a similar theme, Ashley Capps writes in “Saddest Slaughterhouse Footage Ever Shows No Blood or Slaughter,” trapped and panicked cattle who being driven to slaughter “move back and forth like words in a sentence that can’t / be written but desperately keeps rewriting itself.” As they are pushed along, “a man in clothes the color of dirty / snow …into the flesh of the / first cow presses an electric prod. The seared cow panics …”

Of accidental killing, Gretchen Maquette writes in her poem “Painted Turtle,” about driving a summer road “the ring around the lake,” and seeing a turtle in the road. But upon turning the car around to go back and help, “you saw before I did, the fifty / bones of the carapace, / crushed roman dome, the surprise of red blood.”

Similarly, human fascination with certain animals can cause unintended harm to these creatures. Co-editor Allison Titus’s poem, “Pizza the Polar Bear Lives Inside a Display Case Inside a Luxury Shopping Mall in Southern China” captures this catch-22 with poignancy. Pizza, the polar bear, endures tourists who “press against the tempered glass” of his cage, where he “must taste the diamond cold / harsh as a fever when he sleeps.” The poem creates powerful images of the trapped bear including this one: “he smacks his gigantic paw / against an air vent that pumps   a simulated Arctic breeze.”

A poem that acted as a catalyst for the co-editors on their ten-year efforts to create The New Sentience is among those that give voice to not only the anguish of the animal but to the human bearing witness. In Aracelis Girmay’s “To Waste My Hands,” with exquisite, precise, and painful language, Girmay describes watching a shark suffer and die even as the poet laments: “More terrible to waste my hands, just / standing.” The shark is described as “like an angel culled up from the purple sea. / & the air smashed into him like an anvil.”

Balancing poems with relentless and harsh truths, in which things end badly for the animal, there are also poems with tenderness and even happy endings—or at least less sad ending. For instance, Mikko Harvey in the poem “Unearthing” writes of how a gazelle by a pond and the narrator form a kind of dance at night by the water. In the end, the poet writes:

I just sit down

in the crisp grass

and if I wait

like that

for a while then

the gazelle messes

up its long legs and

sits down too

which is a fine

feeling being

at ease together never

having known each

other’s fur.

Respect—as well as tenderness—forms an affective bond in Fady Joudah’s poem “Mimesis,” in which a daughter refuses to move her bike because a spider has built a web between the bicycle’s handles. When the narrator explains to her that if she will “tear down the web” the spider would know the bike wasn’t “a place to call home /And you’d get to go biking.” To this, the daughter replies “that’s how others / Become refugees isn’t it?”

The simple beauty, brilliance, and grace of animal lives are celebrated with joy and vibrant, sensory laden images in a poem by Moses Jumper Jr, titled “Simplicity.” With lines that gloriously capture both moment and scene, the poem observes “The small imprints of the killdeer in the soft white sand near the pond, / …The long, graceful jumps of the sleek, green frog, / …I saw all these things, and many more, and I know they are right.”

The relationship between environmental disaster, climate change, and destruction of the rain forests, and eating animals for food is described with full footnoted documentation in the introduction. In the section titled “Killing Animals, Killing Ourselves,” the introduction tracks that uneasy connection and observes that “farming animals is a major driver of climate change. Climate change is a leading cause of global food insecurity.” In the poems, this link is referenced or alluded to often, including in “Love This,” by Gretchen Primack. She writes of the milk cow whose calf is stolen for veal and that when the cow’s “milk slows too slow / she will join him on the line, pound / of ground. And how we will dine!” Drawing the line between eating that beef and the impacts of climate change from cattle farming, the poem concludes the cow’s body

 

will break up on our forks, as mothers

beg us for the grain we stuffed her with,

and children beg us for the water

scouring her blood from the factory walls.

 

And when her wastes and gases and panic

heat our air so hot our world stops

breathing—then will we stop?

Then will we grow kind,

let the air cool and mothers breathe?

The anthology is impeccably organized, with a foreword by Alexis Pauline Gumbs, an African-American writer, scholar, poet, activist, and educator based in Durham, North Carolina. She says of this collection: “It’s an interspecies family reunion.” The foreword, along with the scholarly introduction with its discussion of poetry techniques, ecology, and animals, helps explain the why and wherefore of these poems. Biographies of each poet are included as well as an alphabetical list of the animals included. This list runs from ants, antelope, and bat to voles, whale, wolf, and worm, with the most poems about birds. Surprisingly perhaps, there are even four poems about cockroaches, including one by Lucille Clifton, the former poet laureate of Maryland. In her poem “the beginning of the end of the world,” Clifton writes:

maybe the morning the roaches

walked into the kitchen

bold with they bad selves

marching up out of the drains

not like soldiers   like priests

…

They seemed to bow their

sad heads   for us not at us…

As well as diversity among animal subjects, there is diversity among the poets included in this anthology with Southern poets well represented. Ashley Capps, co-editor, is a North Carolina resident, and her co-editor, Allison Titus, lives in Virginia. Wendell Berry, well-known environmentalist, farmer, and Kentucky poet; Lucille Clifton; and Terrance Hayes, a National Book Award winner, South Carolina native, and former professor in Louisiana, are among the Southern voices in this varied anthology. The collection also includes selections by poets such as Mary Oliver, E. E. Cummings, Jorie Graham, and Robert Bly that even the most casual poetry readers might recognize. Many other fine, well-credentialed though perhaps lesser-known but no lesser talented poets round out the pages.

As an animal lover, poetry reader, and long-term vegetarian, this reviewer lacks the words to fully describe how truly powerful, important, eloquent, thought-provoking, and emotionally resonant this collection is. In an anthology of this length and breadth, it is hard to even approach capturing the essence of the collection, and so many worthy poets and valuable poems go without comment in the interest of space and word count. Please, do yourself a generous favor and read, study, and savor this book for yourself. It has the power to change your viewpoint, to open your eyes and your mind.

 

Ashley Capps

Co-editor Ashley Capps is the author of a book of poems, Mistaking the Sea for Green Fields, and the recipient of an NEA Fellowship for Poetry. She works as a non-profit writer on issues of animal rights, food, and climate justice and lives in Asheville, North Carolina.

 

 

Allison Titus

Co-editor Allison Titus is the author of the poetry collections High Lonesome, True Book of Animal Homes, and Sum of Every Lost Ship. She teaches in the New England College’s low-residency MFA program and lives in Richmond, Virginia.

To read sample poems and to learn more about The New Sentience, visit: https://thenewsentience.com/

 

 

 

To Waste My Hands

by Aracelis Girmay

(This copyrighted poem first appeared in Kingdom Animalia and is reprinted in The New Sentience. It appears with permission of the Permission Company on behalf of BOA Editions.)

Three years ago, I stood on the dock near my father’s house
while the small shark suffocated & was killed.

He was like an angel culled up from the purple sea.
& the air smashed into him like an anvil

& his muscles sank desperately into the ribs. Terrible

terrible, terrible, terrible, terrible, terrible, terrible
to watch him that way. More terrible to waste my hands, just

standing.

 


Discover more from Southern Literary Review

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Speak Your Mind